Master Pizza Painesville, located at 1640 Mentor Ave, has earned a cherished spot in the hearts of locals over the years. This pizza restaurant prides itself on delivering high-quality, made-to-order pizzas using daily-made crust, homemade sauce, and 100% real cheese. Its diverse menu caters to various tastes, featuring options like the beloved taco pizza and seafood pizza, both noted for their exceptional flavor and consistent quality. Customers rave about the excellent service, with many highlighting their experiences with the friendly staff who are attentive and welcoming. For instance, David Welker’s review emphasizes how the staff handled an order mix-up with grace, ensuring customer satisfaction without any extra charge. The nostalgic ambiance of the old-style pizza shop adds to the charm, complete with red vinyl booths and a selection of refreshing beverages. Desserts, like their delectable cheesecake, provide the perfect ending to the meal. With a reputation for being the best pizza place in Lake County, Master Pizza Painesville is not just a meal—it's a comforting experience steeped in tradition. Whether you're a longtime fan or a first-time visitor, the flavors and atmosphere here promise to keep you coming back for more.
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible car park
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Service options
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Highlights
Has fast service
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves alcohol
Serves coffee
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves wine
Dining options
Serves lunch
Serves dinner
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Crowd
Good for groups
Popular with university students
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Accepts NFC mobile payments
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
High chairs available
Has kids' menu
Parking
Free parking lot
Plenty of parking
Photos
Reviews For Master Pizza Painesville
David Welker
May 29,2025
My favorite pizza in Lake County! I grew up eating Master Pizza and have always enjoyed it. In our latest stop we ordered (1) small sausage & mushroom, pepperoni & tomatoes, pepperoni, jalapenos & mushroom all with extra cheese. Our super friendly server had a little mix up and brought out a jalapeno & mudhroom instead of the sausage. She made it right - put it in a to go box for us and brought out the right one (didn't charge us for either). Excellent pizza & great service can be expected!
Michael Ludwick
May 20,2025
Last night my wife and I ordered a large taco and sm seafood pizza. They were tremendous as always and the consistency of quality throughout the years has hardly wavered. FYI taco pizza next morning cold was awesome. If you're not a cold pizza fan I recommend asking for the lettuce on the side. Also highly recommend the master pizza it's my go to for a supreme with everything.
Michael Shaffer
May 1,2025
Love this place fir Authentic pizza. My wife and I have enjoyed Master Pizza at this location for over 40 years. Crust, sausage, and sauce are unique and delicious!
michael warat
Mar 31,2025
Old style pizza shoppe. Red vinyl booths. Good pizza. Beer and wine.
Aimee French
Mar 25,2025
Master pizza in Painesville is the only place I order pizza from. They have the absolute best and alot of different choices. Their other food is just as amazing as the pizza. The staff are wonderful also. The best pizza place in the county
Melissa Yeary
Mar 10,2025
Always my favorite! Only disappointment is we only got one pizza and there were no leftovers!
Dona Taylor
Feb 27,2025
My favorite pizza since I was a teenager. I’ve had pizza at pizza places all over and I always come back to Master Pizza because there’s is always great!!
Marc Barricelli
Feb 22,2025
Old school family Italian restaurant. Pizza was excellent.
Reviews For Master Pizza Painesville